December 4, 2018
Present: Judges Donnelly, Essner,
Zellweger, Dunne, Schroeder, Hardin-Tammons, and Hilton, Commissioner Cunningham,
Tom Weber, Terri Johnson, Cindy Smith, Ben Burkemper, and Michelle LaBeaume
The following non-members were present for the Disproportionate Minority Contact presentation: Jacqueline Cuncannan and Emily Keller, attorneys from the Department of Justice, Mark Greenwald, Director of Research for the Florida Department of Juvenile Justice and DMC Auditor, Mark Grim, retired Judge from Berks County, Pennsylvania and Independent Auditor, and Brad Wing, the Research Manager for the Family Court.
Disproportionate Minority Contact
Bi-Annual Report Presentation
distributed a handout entitled, “In the Best Interest of our Kids: An
Examination of 2017 – 2018 Disproportionate Minority Contact Data.” He provided
a power point presentation for the Bi-Annual Report.
As part of
Brad’s presentation, he discussed the results of the 3rd Bi-Annual
DMC Report. He collected and examined
data from July 1, 2017 through June 30, 2018.
The data contained an overlap with the previous report period from the 2nd
Bi-Annual report that covered the calendar year 2017. He wanted to include current data for the
first half of 2018 to have a sufficient amount of data to do the analysis.
Brad gave an
overview of what the frequency data shows in terms of representation of various
youth by race and ethnicity at each contact point: referrals, referrals
informally resolved, secure detention admissions, petitioners, formal cases in
which the Court found charges of delinquency to be true, commitments to DYS,
and certifications to adult court. He showed the disproportionate minority
contact relative rate indices that are designed to detect disproportionality at
each contact point and whether one group has more contact with the juvenile justice
system than another group at any of the points mentioned above.
A synopsis of
the data showed the large volume of referrals of black youth at the front end were
disproportionate. With the large number
of referrals of black youth at the front end, it was determined that this
influences every subsequent contact point. While the Family Court cannot
control what is referred, Brad stated that it is important to work on referrals
with community partners and referral sources.
Statistical evidence shows that this large volume translates into
disproportionality for black youth at several stages in the juvenile justice
indicated it is essential to find other means to address the needs of the youth
and to get a handle on referrals that are made that are found to be
insufficient and to reduce the likelihood that law enforcement agencies will
make certain referrals that will very likely be rejected.
Brad delivered the same power point presentation at the Administration Building
of the University City School District. The
Court partnered with the Children’s Services Fund staff to advertise the event
in hopes to recruit community partners and family members to attend. The plan
was to ensure the understanding of the issues and find strategies going forward
to address any issues of disproportionality and disparities.
No report was
A motion was
made by Judge Hilton, seconded by Judge Schroeder, to adjourn the meeting. All were in favor.